William Kristof (NYT 7/3/14) neglects the important role American universities played in building America's infrastructure by supplying the country early on with trained engineers. West Point is the birthplace of American engineering where Sylvanus Thayer and Dennis Hart Mahan established a program that produced many engineers and eventually seeded universities across the country with texts and professors. Mahan almost singlehanded transferred the engineering expertise of France to America. It testament to America's ancient and better angels that WASP Puritan Thayer took Mahan, the child of Irish immigrants, as his protégé, although our tradition of Anglo-German Exceptionalism and Ivy League history departments rooted in the glory of our Puritan past makes that difficult to acknowledge today. On the 151th anniversary of the battle of Gettysburg and the 238th of our Independence, it is worth noting that Union Army Gettysburg commander George Gordon Meade's first job after graduating from West Point was surveying the route for the Long Island Railroad, and that he'd been born in Cadiz, Spain.
------------------
Mahan's son Alfred Thayer wrote America's second great chapter: Sea Power, which inspired the creation of the modern U.S. Navy. Following in the footsteps of Mahan's friend Teddy, Franklin Roosevelt embarked on a massive shipbuilding program that saved America and Western Civilization. This shipbuilding program put thousands of Americans to work in the 1930s and built the Navy that was America's defense against fascism in the Pacific and Europe's lifeline to freedom in the Atlantic. The hi-tech Yorktown aircraft carriers started in the 1930s defeated the Japanese at Midway in June of 1942 despite being outnumbered on paper. In fact the Yorktown's carried as many aircraft as the Japanese fleet and the Yorktown's aircraft complement included squadrons of the hi-tech SBG dive bombers, which delivered the battle's decisive blows.
Monday, July 21, 2014
Sunday, July 20, 2014
No Such Army
A letter (7/19) in The Times Book Review commenting on the Clouds of Glory biography of Robert E. Lee attributes the following to C.S.A. Gen. Joe Johnson describing the Union force led by Gen. Sherman: there had been "no such army since the days of Julius Caesar."
No doubt Napoleon Bonaparte would object to Johnson's remark. Bonaparte led an army ten times the size of Sherman's into Russia, fighting titanic battles that inspired Tchaikovsky's 1812 Overture and Tolstoy's War and Peace.
Winston Churchill would be vexed, too. His ancestor, the Duke of Marlborough, marched an army about the same size as Sherman's with as many artillery guns from Brussels to the Danube, a distance greater than Sherman's march from Atlanta to Savanah. For his great victory over France at Blenheim on the Danube, Marlborough was awarded the magnificent Blenheim Palace in Oxfordshire, Winston Churchill's birthplace, now a World Heritage Site.
Apparently national pride has a great deal to do with how we remember things, since neither Tolstoy, nor Tchaikovsky, nor Churchill were ever moved to remark on Sherman's campaigns, a slight compounded by the fact that Churchill and Sherman were cousins. It's a safe bet, though, that Sherman knew about the Duke of Marlborough and Marlborough's great campaigns on behalf of England's Glorious Revolution, William III (aka William of Orange-Nassau) and Queen Anne.
Then there's the small matter of the armies Robert E. Lee and George Gordon Meade marched hundreds of miles across Virginia, Maryland and Pennsylvania in 1863.
http://hidden-civil-war.blogspot.com/2013/08/the-great-militia-mobilization-of-june.html
It is fair to say that The Times, its readers and most American historians are quite parochial.
No doubt Napoleon Bonaparte would object to Johnson's remark. Bonaparte led an army ten times the size of Sherman's into Russia, fighting titanic battles that inspired Tchaikovsky's 1812 Overture and Tolstoy's War and Peace.
Winston Churchill would be vexed, too. His ancestor, the Duke of Marlborough, marched an army about the same size as Sherman's with as many artillery guns from Brussels to the Danube, a distance greater than Sherman's march from Atlanta to Savanah. For his great victory over France at Blenheim on the Danube, Marlborough was awarded the magnificent Blenheim Palace in Oxfordshire, Winston Churchill's birthplace, now a World Heritage Site.
Apparently national pride has a great deal to do with how we remember things, since neither Tolstoy, nor Tchaikovsky, nor Churchill were ever moved to remark on Sherman's campaigns, a slight compounded by the fact that Churchill and Sherman were cousins. It's a safe bet, though, that Sherman knew about the Duke of Marlborough and Marlborough's great campaigns on behalf of England's Glorious Revolution, William III (aka William of Orange-Nassau) and Queen Anne.
Then there's the small matter of the armies Robert E. Lee and George Gordon Meade marched hundreds of miles across Virginia, Maryland and Pennsylvania in 1863.
http://hidden-civil-war.blogspot.com/2013/08/the-great-militia-mobilization-of-june.html
It is fair to say that The Times, its readers and most American historians are quite parochial.
Sunday, June 29, 2014
Hasn't Anyone Here Heard of Thucydides?
Regarding Fergus Bordewich's review of Michael Korda's Clouds of Glory, a Robert E. Lee biography, hasn't anyone here heard of Thucydides? Bordewich is right in taking Korda to task for egregiously exaggerating Sherman's crimes against civilians during America's Civil War. But Bordwich should have objected as well to Korda's claim that "Sherman introduced what a later generation would call total war, involving the burning of cities, homes and farms on a wide scale." Sherman's war on the Southern economy was in fact an ancient "art." It was employed by Sparta against Athens famously remembered in the History of the Peloponnesian War written by the Greek historian Thucydides. "Cathago delenta est" is the famous phrase with which Cato the Elder would end every speech, regardless of subject, and in the Third Punic war that is exactly what Rome did to Carthage. The Romans burned the city to the ground, sowed its fields with salt, and sold the 50,000 survivors into slavery. It is really too bad that the classics apparently are no longer required reading for today's historians.
Only egregious American exceptionalism and victimhood allows us to overlook the violence of the Napoleonic Wars, particularly in Spain and Russia. The Russians destroyed their own farms to starve the invading French. The French famously burned Moscow. The French shot straggling Russian prisoners during their retreat. The Russians took no prisoners as they hectored the fleeing French. Tolstoy recalls in War and Peace, the ruthless Dolokhov coldly reasoning that it was a waste of time taking prisoners who would starve or freeze to death in a day or two.

Goya's "The Executions of the Third of May, 1808" similarly recalls the savagery of the French in dealing with Spanish partisans.
The Napoleonic Wars were not simply something American officers studied at West Point prior to the Civil War. They were a reality of the era. George Gordon Meade commander of the Union army at Gettysburg was born in Spain to an American merchant who lost his fortune financing the Spanish resistance.
Only egregious American exceptionalism and victimhood allows us to overlook the violence of the Napoleonic Wars, particularly in Spain and Russia. The Russians destroyed their own farms to starve the invading French. The French famously burned Moscow. The French shot straggling Russian prisoners during their retreat. The Russians took no prisoners as they hectored the fleeing French. Tolstoy recalls in War and Peace, the ruthless Dolokhov coldly reasoning that it was a waste of time taking prisoners who would starve or freeze to death in a day or two.
Goya's "The Executions of the Third of May, 1808" similarly recalls the savagery of the French in dealing with Spanish partisans.
The Napoleonic Wars were not simply something American officers studied at West Point prior to the Civil War. They were a reality of the era. George Gordon Meade commander of the Union army at Gettysburg was born in Spain to an American merchant who lost his fortune financing the Spanish resistance.
Thursday, May 15, 2014
Ivy League Confederates: Columbia and Yale Et Al
It would surprise some to learn that 20 percent of all Harvard alumni who served in the Civil War fought for the South (357 - Crimson Confederates, Helen Trimpi) and that those serving in the Confederate military included five major generals and eight brigadier generals, three of whom were killed in battle. Major General Richard Taylor who attended Harvard and Yale (1845) served throughout the war commanding many Louisiana units, including the famous "Tigers", and defeated (humiliated) Union General Nathaniel Banks during the Red River campaign in 1864.
More than 500 Yale men served the Confederacy in some capacity (Yale's Confederates - Nathaniel Hughes). Graduate Judah Benjamin was the Confederacy's Secretary of State and Secretary of War. Samuel Morse was a prominent public opponent of Lincoln and Emancipation. Senator John Calhoun was a prominent advocate for the Fugitive Slave Law and opponent of abolition. Eli Whitney invented the cotton gin which set the stage for industrial scale cotton production and slavery in America. It is remarkable to read Whitney's letters concerning the invention and his schemes for plantations in the South and encounter the utter disregard for slave labor he was enabling and personally exploiting.
Princeton University had a very strong to connection with the South. According to the Princeton Alumni Weekly over 200 Princeton alumni enlisted in the Confederate service, including at least seven brigadier generals. John C. Breckinridge, US Vice President and Confederate general, attended Princeton (1838-39) for graduate study. "U.S. Supreme Court justice James Wayne 1808 concurred in the Dred Scott decision that claimed black Americans had 'no rights which the white man was bound to respect.'” Twenty-two ante-bellum US Senators were educated at Princeton, including Alfred Iverson who "gave ferocious speeches threatening secession." Rev. George Armstrong 1832 wrote The Christian Doctrine of Slavery in 1857, arguing that slaves enjoyed better protections against capitalist exploitation by the rich than did poor whites in the North. http://paw.princeton.edu/issues/2011/03/23/pages/4092/index.xml
Richard Sears McCulloh, scion of an old Scots Protestant Maryland family, graduate of Princeton and Columbia University professor of chemistry was possibly the New York City draft riots principal arsonist. He turned up in Richmond after the riots, offering to make weapons of mass destruction for the Confederacy. He eventually weaponized poison gas, but not in time for it to be used in the war.
Columbia University's most famous Confederate was John Slidell, a New Yorker who transplanted to Louisiana and became a US Senator. Slidell became involved with the Trent Affair after being appointed Confederate emissary to France when he was captured by the Union while transiting the Atlantic aboard British steamer RMS Trent. August Belmont, leader of the North's "loyal" Democrats and American agent for the Rothschilds, became Slidell's protégé after he married Slidell's niece.
The notorious Bradish Johnson also should be numbered among Columbia's Confederates. Johnson was the business partner of Moses Lazarus, father of poet Emma Lazarus. Johnson & Lazarus owned sugar refining and distilling operations in New York City and dairies that used the distillery byproducts to feed the cows. The Johnson & Lazarus "swill" milk that allegedly killed thousands of New York children became the subject of Frank Leslie's famous muckraking expose. The sugar for the distilleries came from plantations Johnson owned in Louisiana. During the Civil War Johnson had the audacity to petition Lincoln to readmit Louisiana as a slave state, and sued the Union army for "plundering" his plantations.
Like Columbia, Brown is less forthcoming about its Confederate army sons, but Brown has done a remarkable job exposing its and Rhode Island's deep and profitable involvement with the slave trade.
More than 500 Yale men served the Confederacy in some capacity (Yale's Confederates - Nathaniel Hughes). Graduate Judah Benjamin was the Confederacy's Secretary of State and Secretary of War. Samuel Morse was a prominent public opponent of Lincoln and Emancipation. Senator John Calhoun was a prominent advocate for the Fugitive Slave Law and opponent of abolition. Eli Whitney invented the cotton gin which set the stage for industrial scale cotton production and slavery in America. It is remarkable to read Whitney's letters concerning the invention and his schemes for plantations in the South and encounter the utter disregard for slave labor he was enabling and personally exploiting.
Princeton University had a very strong to connection with the South. According to the Princeton Alumni Weekly over 200 Princeton alumni enlisted in the Confederate service, including at least seven brigadier generals. John C. Breckinridge, US Vice President and Confederate general, attended Princeton (1838-39) for graduate study. "U.S. Supreme Court justice James Wayne 1808 concurred in the Dred Scott decision that claimed black Americans had 'no rights which the white man was bound to respect.'” Twenty-two ante-bellum US Senators were educated at Princeton, including Alfred Iverson who "gave ferocious speeches threatening secession." Rev. George Armstrong 1832 wrote The Christian Doctrine of Slavery in 1857, arguing that slaves enjoyed better protections against capitalist exploitation by the rich than did poor whites in the North. http://paw.princeton.edu/issues/2011/03/23/pages/4092/index.xml
Richard Sears McCulloh, scion of an old Scots Protestant Maryland family, graduate of Princeton and Columbia University professor of chemistry was possibly the New York City draft riots principal arsonist. He turned up in Richmond after the riots, offering to make weapons of mass destruction for the Confederacy. He eventually weaponized poison gas, but not in time for it to be used in the war.
Columbia University's most famous Confederate was John Slidell, a New Yorker who transplanted to Louisiana and became a US Senator. Slidell became involved with the Trent Affair after being appointed Confederate emissary to France when he was captured by the Union while transiting the Atlantic aboard British steamer RMS Trent. August Belmont, leader of the North's "loyal" Democrats and American agent for the Rothschilds, became Slidell's protégé after he married Slidell's niece.
The notorious Bradish Johnson also should be numbered among Columbia's Confederates. Johnson was the business partner of Moses Lazarus, father of poet Emma Lazarus. Johnson & Lazarus owned sugar refining and distilling operations in New York City and dairies that used the distillery byproducts to feed the cows. The Johnson & Lazarus "swill" milk that allegedly killed thousands of New York children became the subject of Frank Leslie's famous muckraking expose. The sugar for the distilleries came from plantations Johnson owned in Louisiana. During the Civil War Johnson had the audacity to petition Lincoln to readmit Louisiana as a slave state, and sued the Union army for "plundering" his plantations.
Like Columbia, Brown is less forthcoming about its Confederate army sons, but Brown has done a remarkable job exposing its and Rhode Island's deep and profitable involvement with the slave trade.
http://www.brown.edu/Research/Slavery_Justice/report/
Arguably, The University of Pennsylvania's most prominent Confederate was James Murray Mason (1818), Confederate envoy to Britain, who was caught up in The Trent affair with Slidell. However, alumnus General John C. Pemberton, CSA, surrendered his army to Grant at Vicksburg, Miss., July 4, 1863. Teddy Roosevelt's uncle Irvine Bulloch left Penn to serve on the Confederate raider Alabama, which his brother James, the Confederacy's agent in England, had procured to wage war on the high seas against the Union.
https://ia600307.us.archive.org/21/items/universityofpenn01jord/universityofpenn01jord.pdf
Arguably, The University of Pennsylvania's most prominent Confederate was James Murray Mason (1818), Confederate envoy to Britain, who was caught up in The Trent affair with Slidell. However, alumnus General John C. Pemberton, CSA, surrendered his army to Grant at Vicksburg, Miss., July 4, 1863. Teddy Roosevelt's uncle Irvine Bulloch left Penn to serve on the Confederate raider Alabama, which his brother James, the Confederacy's agent in England, had procured to wage war on the high seas against the Union.
https://ia600307.us.archive.org/21/items/universityofpenn01jord/universityofpenn01jord.pdf
Wednesday, April 9, 2014
New York City's Soldiers Monuments
The Soldiers’ Monument at Green-Wood Cemetery, erected only four years after the end of the Civil War, was an early monument but not the first in the city. In 1866, the City of New York erected a monument at Calvary Catholic Cemetery in Queens, which has the identical four statues as Green-Wood, except that they are cast in bronze, almost certainly from the same sculptures by Daniel Draddy. These “public” monuments, located in two large cemeteries outside Manhattan, were fitting commemorative gestures to honor the many veterans who were in fact continuing to die in some numbers due to wounds and disease incurred during the still recent war between the states. Some of the dead were also brought home from distant battlefields.
200,000 soldiers and sailors from New York City fought for the Union. 20,000 of them died while serving the Union and over 200 were awarded the Medal of Honor. More than half of New York City's soldiers and sailors were immigrants with the largest group being Irish.
Green-Wood Soldiers' Monument
https://www.green-wood.com/2010/civil-war-soldiers-monument-saved/
Calvary Cemetery Soldiers' Monument

Scupltor: Daniel Draddy
http://www.nycgovparks.org/parks/Q224/monuments/1467
200,000 soldiers and sailors from New York City fought for the Union. 20,000 of them died while serving the Union and over 200 were awarded the Medal of Honor. More than half of New York City's soldiers and sailors were immigrants with the largest group being Irish.
Green-Wood Soldiers' Monument
https://www.green-wood.com/2010/civil-war-soldiers-monument-saved/
Calvary Cemetery Soldiers' Monument
Scupltor: Daniel Draddy
http://www.nycgovparks.org/parks/Q224/monuments/1467
Monday, March 17, 2014
The Last Irish Medal of Honor
The Times interesting story about Okinawa and its version of "Danny Boy" by Isamu Shimoji and Yukito Ara missed the unique connection between that Emerald Isle and New York's Irish. New York's fabled "Fighting Irish" 69th regiment won its last Medal of Honor for valor above and beyond the call of duty on April 28, 1945 when Pfc Alejandro Ruiz single-handed stormed and captured a heavily defended Japanese position. A representative of the 69th read Joyce Kilmer's "The Rouge Bouquet" at Ruiz's funeral in 2010 while a piper played the regimental song "Gary Owen."Above the "Mourning Wolfhound Irish Brigade Monument" at Gettysburg. On Okinawa the Irish Brigade aka the "Fighing Irish" 69th NYNG fought as the 165th Infantry Regiment.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/17/opinion/the-flute-the-flute-is-calling.html
IN a wood they call the Rouge Bouquet | |
| There is a new-made grave to-day, | |
| Built by never a spade nor pick | |
| Yet covered with earth ten metres thick. | |
| There lie many fighting men, | 5 |
| Dead in their youthful prime, | |
| Never to laugh nor love again | |
| Nor taste the Summertime. | |
| For Death came flying through the air | |
| And stopped his flight at the dugout stair, | 10 |
| Touched his prey and left them there, | |
| Clay to clay. | |
| He hid their bodies stealthily | |
| In the soil of the land they fought to free | |
| And fled away. | 15 |
| Now over the grave abrupt and clear | |
| Three volleys ring; | |
| And perhaps their brave young spirits hear | |
| The bugle sing: | |
| “Go to sleep! | 20 |
| Go to sleep! | |
| Slumber well where the shell screamed and fell. | |
| Let your rifles rest on the muddy floor, | |
| You will not need them any more. | |
| Danger’s past; | 25 |
| Now at last, | |
| Go to sleep!” | |
| There is on earth no worthier grave | |
| To hold the bodies of the brave | |
| Than this place of pain and pride | 30 |
| Where they nobly fought and nobly died. | |
| Never fear but in the skies | |
| Saints and angels stand | |
| Smiling with their holy eyes | |
| On this new-come band. | 35 |
| St. Michael’s sword darts through the air | |
| And touches the aureole on his hair | |
| As he sees them stand saluting there, | |
| His stalwart sons; | |
| And Patrick, Brigid, Columkill | 40 |
| Rejoice that in veins of warriors still | |
| The Gael’s blood runs. | |
| And up to Heaven’s doorway floats, | |
| From the wood called Rouge Bouquet, | |
| A delicate cloud of buglenotes | 45 |
| That softly say: | |
| “Farewell! | |
| Farewell! | |
| Comrades true, born anew, peace to you! | |
| Your souls shall be where the heroes are | 50 |
| And your memory shine like the morning-star. | |
| Brave and dear, | |
| Shield us here. | |
| Farewell!” |
Why is McPherson Anti-Catholic
Andrew Greely, the Jesuit sociologist and author, once remarked to me about Princeton's James McPherson: "Why is such an otherwise fine historian so anti-Catholic." The following raise that question.
"Immigrants were proportionally under-represented in the Union’s armed services...Despite the fighting reputation of the Irish Brigade, the Irish were the most under-represented group in proportion to population, followed by German Catholics."
- James M. McPherson, Battle Cry of Freedom, p 606, 1988
"The under-representation of Catholic immigrants can be explained in part by Democratic allegiance of these groups and their opposition to Republican war aims, especially emancipation...Although this group furnished a large number of substitutes and bounty men during the final year of the war — thereby achieving an inglorious visibility — they also furnished a large number of deserters and bounty jumpers."
- James M. McPherson, Battle Cry of Freedom, p. 607, 1988
The problem with Professor McPherson's remarks start with the Union army never recording the religion of its soldiers. Who could possibly know how many were, in fact, Catholic.
The second problem is that there are no census records available telling us exactly how many Catholics, or even Irish, were available for military service during America's Civil War.
The last and most egregious problem is that historians including McPherson confuse the Sanitary Commission Report estimate for the number of Irish born soldiers serving in state volunteer units with the number of Irish serving with Union forces. The Sanitary Commission Report estimate did not include soldiers in regular army units, nor most from the territories, nor militia units and excluded all the marines and sailors. Moreover, as acknowledged in the Sanitary Commission report the Union army did not record place of birth for 43 percent of the soldiers. Not surprisingly, the highest levels of failure to record were in states with the highest concentration of immigrants: Massachusetts, New York, and Pennsylvania.
(http://hidden-civil-war.blogspot.com/2013/11/the-unions-irish-soldiers-and-sailors.html)
At the University of Virginia, for example, misrepresenting a source is considered academic fraud:
False Citation: False citation is falsely citing a source or attributing work
to a source from which the referenced material was not obtained.
A simple example of this would be footnoting a paragraph and citing a work
that was never utilized.
Estimates adjusting for Sanitary Commission omissions and separately on Medal of Honor data put the number of Irish born serving with the Union army and navy at over 200,000, at least 50 higher than the uncorrected Sanitary Commission estimate.
Why did Professor McPherson make such an egregious mistake? Inherited prejudice.
"I share [with my cousin] a great-great-grandfather who fought in the Civil War. This man, Jesse Beecher, emigrated from England in 1857 and became a prosperous wheelwright in an upstate New York village....Another clue [to why he served] is provided by the name he bestowed on his first child born in the United States: Henry Ward Beecher, after the famous antislavery clergyman."
- James M. McPherson, For Cause and Comrades, p 4, 1997
While fans of the Beechers like to remember Harriet and Henry Ward as abolitionists, they avoid mentioning that others in the family were among America's most prominent and rabid anti-Catholics. Their father Lyman was the author of the widely read anti-Catholic diatribe A Plea for the West, whose fiery sermons instigated the Ursuline Convent Riots in 1834. In 1855, Beecher's son Edward authored The Papal Conspiracy Exposed, of which Orestes Brownson observed: "Dr. Beecher is haunted by strange visions of a papal conspiracy against American Protestantism and American liberty, and in his agitated dreams he calls out upon his countrymen to put an extinguisher upon Catholicity."
http://hidden-civil-war.blogspot.com/2013/08/the-generals-and-small-catholic-church.html
http://hidden-civil-war.blogspot.com/2013/08/the-norths-greatest-hispanic-general.html
http://hidden-civil-war.blogspot.com/2013/08/nessun-dorma-fighting-irish-assault.html
Never mind that Princeton University's other name is "Old Nassau", a celebration of William of Orange-Nassau, the Dutch conqueror of England and victor at Ireland's Battle of the Boyne, which sealed the tragic fate of Ireland's Gaelic-speaking Catholic peasantry, writing in stone the proto-Apartheid Penal Laws which oppressed the Irish even into the 20th century.
---------------------------
That the history profession accepted McPherson's egregious canards without objection can be summed up in The New York Times choice of reviewer for the book: Hugh Brogan, a British historian, whose only objection was to the grey background of the book's maps.
http://www.nytimes.com/books/98/12/06/specials/mcpherson-freedom.html
---------------------------
Make a racist or anti-Semitic remark and you'll lose your job or your business. Defame the Irish and the Catholics and they award you the Pulitzer Prize.
"Immigrants were proportionally under-represented in the Union’s armed services...Despite the fighting reputation of the Irish Brigade, the Irish were the most under-represented group in proportion to population, followed by German Catholics."
- James M. McPherson, Battle Cry of Freedom, p 606, 1988
"The under-representation of Catholic immigrants can be explained in part by Democratic allegiance of these groups and their opposition to Republican war aims, especially emancipation...Although this group furnished a large number of substitutes and bounty men during the final year of the war — thereby achieving an inglorious visibility — they also furnished a large number of deserters and bounty jumpers."
- James M. McPherson, Battle Cry of Freedom, p. 607, 1988
The problem with Professor McPherson's remarks start with the Union army never recording the religion of its soldiers. Who could possibly know how many were, in fact, Catholic.
The second problem is that there are no census records available telling us exactly how many Catholics, or even Irish, were available for military service during America's Civil War.
The last and most egregious problem is that historians including McPherson confuse the Sanitary Commission Report estimate for the number of Irish born soldiers serving in state volunteer units with the number of Irish serving with Union forces. The Sanitary Commission Report estimate did not include soldiers in regular army units, nor most from the territories, nor militia units and excluded all the marines and sailors. Moreover, as acknowledged in the Sanitary Commission report the Union army did not record place of birth for 43 percent of the soldiers. Not surprisingly, the highest levels of failure to record were in states with the highest concentration of immigrants: Massachusetts, New York, and Pennsylvania.
(http://hidden-civil-war.blogspot.com/2013/11/the-unions-irish-soldiers-and-sailors.html)
At the University of Virginia, for example, misrepresenting a source is considered academic fraud:
False Citation: False citation is falsely citing a source or attributing work
to a source from which the referenced material was not obtained.
A simple example of this would be footnoting a paragraph and citing a work
that was never utilized.
Estimates adjusting for Sanitary Commission omissions and separately on Medal of Honor data put the number of Irish born serving with the Union army and navy at over 200,000, at least 50 higher than the uncorrected Sanitary Commission estimate.
Why did Professor McPherson make such an egregious mistake? Inherited prejudice.
"I share [with my cousin] a great-great-grandfather who fought in the Civil War. This man, Jesse Beecher, emigrated from England in 1857 and became a prosperous wheelwright in an upstate New York village....Another clue [to why he served] is provided by the name he bestowed on his first child born in the United States: Henry Ward Beecher, after the famous antislavery clergyman."
- James M. McPherson, For Cause and Comrades, p 4, 1997
While fans of the Beechers like to remember Harriet and Henry Ward as abolitionists, they avoid mentioning that others in the family were among America's most prominent and rabid anti-Catholics. Their father Lyman was the author of the widely read anti-Catholic diatribe A Plea for the West, whose fiery sermons instigated the Ursuline Convent Riots in 1834. In 1855, Beecher's son Edward authored The Papal Conspiracy Exposed, of which Orestes Brownson observed: "Dr. Beecher is haunted by strange visions of a papal conspiracy against American Protestantism and American liberty, and in his agitated dreams he calls out upon his countrymen to put an extinguisher upon Catholicity."
http://hidden-civil-war.blogspot.com/2013/08/the-generals-and-small-catholic-church.html
http://hidden-civil-war.blogspot.com/2013/08/the-norths-greatest-hispanic-general.html
http://hidden-civil-war.blogspot.com/2013/08/nessun-dorma-fighting-irish-assault.html
Never mind that Princeton University's other name is "Old Nassau", a celebration of William of Orange-Nassau, the Dutch conqueror of England and victor at Ireland's Battle of the Boyne, which sealed the tragic fate of Ireland's Gaelic-speaking Catholic peasantry, writing in stone the proto-Apartheid Penal Laws which oppressed the Irish even into the 20th century.
---------------------------
That the history profession accepted McPherson's egregious canards without objection can be summed up in The New York Times choice of reviewer for the book: Hugh Brogan, a British historian, whose only objection was to the grey background of the book's maps.
http://www.nytimes.com/books/98/12/06/specials/mcpherson-freedom.html
---------------------------
Make a racist or anti-Semitic remark and you'll lose your job or your business. Defame the Irish and the Catholics and they award you the Pulitzer Prize.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)